Yeats’ ‘The Second Coming’ as a Commentary of the Downfall of the Christian Era
To the uninitiated, Yeats’ ‘The Second Coming’ seems like a retelling of an apocalyptic prophecy not dissimilar to the Book of Revelation in the Bible, in which the narrator of the poem takes the place of John the Evangelist in describing his vision of Armageddon. However, if we refer to the context in which it was written, especially with regard to Yeats’ view of history[1], we can see very clearly that the poem is a commentary of the ending of the current Christian era from Yeats’ point of view. In this essay, it is my purpose to first show the two interpretations of the poem – the Christian apocalypse and Yeats’ view of history, and then prove that the use of Christian imagery is essential in conveying his ideas regarding the downfall of the Christian era.
The poem starts with a vague AABB rhyming scheme in the first four lines that comprise half rhymes rather than fully consonant ones; it then loses its rhyming scheme for free verse from the fifth line onwards. This, supported by the circular motion of the falcon in the first two lines – with circles as symbols of order and perfection – helps to portray an image of regularity and peace that gives way to the chaos caused by the imagery of the opening of the floodgates of the Biblical flood given by words such ‘loosed’, ‘tide’, and ‘drowned’. Henceforth, the poem starts in another stanza that starts with repetition of ‘the Second Coming’ and ‘is at hand’, emphasizing the immediacy of the event that is to come – the coming of a messiah that will save the world from the chaos experienced in stanza one.
It is here, however, that the Christian imagery ceases, and the reader’s expectation of the person described in the Second Coming – Christ – is shaken by Yeats’; instead, the so-called messiah is not described as Christ, but as the Egyptian Sphinx that carries with it very beastly images: images of the body rather than of the soul, of darkness and pitilessness rather than light and mercy, where the Spirit of the World (Spiritus Mundi) replaces the Holy Spirit (Spiritus Sancti) as the cause of divine inspiration. An antichrist, as it may. In this stanza, the interpretation of the poem as a retelling of the Christian apocalypse fails to hold, and has to be explained using Yeats’ personal views of history.
Using this alternative viewpoint, we can see that Yeats is writing a commentary of the downfall of the Christian era, which begins with an increase in the distance between God (the falconer) and Man (the falcon) and leading to anarchy, where the ‘ceremony’ of innocence is just that – a meaningless façade that hides beneath it the truth about the beastly nature of man – and finally gives way to herald the solution in stanza two. Furthermore, the flood references serve to back up Yeats’ view of history by implicitly referring to a recurring theme in human mythology – Man’s separation from God and his reconciliation after a manifestation of the divine persona: Noah and the Ark, the Incarnation of Christ, the ten Hindu avatars that appeared in the ten eras of the world just before its destruction and recreation by Shiva and Brahma respectively, and so on. And as a conclusion, the stanza ends with Yeats poking fun at the denominations of Christianity: the Catholics who ‘lack all [conviction]’ in pursuing their faith, and the Protestants ‘full of passionate intensity’ to call down hellfire on those who would dare to believe otherwise.
In stanza two, Yeats then describes the vision he has of the ending of the current era and the beginning of the next, a vision inspired by the Spirit of the World and ending as ‘the darkness drops again’ with his realization its meaning. Herein the ‘birds’ that may very well be the doves used to represent the Holy Spirit in Christianity are reduced to shadows and are replaced by the beastly Sphinx, the Sphinx that was stirred from its ‘twenty centuries’ of sleep since the start of the Egyptian Civilization by the Nativity of Christ’s ‘rocking cradle’ and which was slowly awakened as the Christian era lost its influence on man. It then ends by posing a question to the reader as to the identity of the second messiah, one described as a ‘rough beast’ and what Yeats calls an “antithetical opposite” of Christ[2].
After looking at both interpretations, we can easily conclude that Yeats first applied familiar Christian imagery to first draw in the reader, used the poem as a medium of explaining his historical theory, and then finally used it to describe the position of the Christian era in history.
[1] In his book ‘A Vision’, Yeats theorised that history is made up of cycles of many successive eras, each starting from a specific event in time (e.g. Christ’s birth), and increasing and decreasing in influence until replaced by the next era. As a detailed explanation here would take up a lot of space and an overly unnecessary knowledge of geometry, one will not be given. However, further insights to the matter can be obtained from http://www.yeatsvision.com/History.html.
[2] Another aspect of Yeats’ theory of history that really isn’t very relevant to this essay but is always good to know for those curious about his philosophical leanings. More on this can also be found at http://www.yeatsvision.com/History.html.
“The Second Coming”, Macbeth, and the Art of Reading: An Investigation into the Derivation of Meaning from a Text upon the Understanding of the Author
The interaction between author, text, and reader to elicit meaning out of the text is an oft-discussed topic in the literary world, perhaps better known to many people by its more widely-used moniker: the act of reading. In this paper, I will strive to examine how each of the three components of the reading process – author, text, and reader – individually contribute to meaning, and how their interaction ultimately results in the emergence of the final meaning of the text; it is also my purpose to prove that in the transaction between these three components, although the interpreted meaning will differ from reader to reader, the interpretation of the text closest to the vision of the author can only be obtained through study of the context in which the author wrote it. To further this purpose, I will be using Yeats’ “The Second Coming” and Shakespeare’s Macbeth as examples.
When an author creates a work, there inevitably is a reason, a push, behind his inspiration to create: Owen was spurred on by the horrors he encountered in the Great War; Luther, to right the so-called abuses in the church; Shakespeare, to appease the King as part of his job as royal playwright. And after this inspiration has struck, the authors go on to craft a work with the goal of conveying this reason behind his inspiration to the reader: the text.
A text can be called a physical manifestation of an author’s thoughts on paper; a way of conveying to the reader the author’s ideas, intentions, feelings. In as much as we send letters (or in this modern age, e-mails) over great distances to acquaintances as a way of transmitting information, an author writes a work (or text), which then traverses the great distances of space and time to its reader, which then reads it and interpret it as he sees fit. That is the role of the text.
And for the reader, after being the recipient of the author’s ideas, he interprets the text in his own context; different readers, as will be further elaborated on later in this paper, will interpret the same text in different ways by using their experiences, knowledge, and beliefs to construct an understanding of the text that will be substantially different from that of another person. Hence, in this way, different readers will be able to elicit different meanings out of a single text.
We can then see that in this author-text-reader relationship, the author acts to convey his meaning to the reader through his text, and crafts the text in a way so as to best express his intended meaning to the reader (in the previous analogy of the e-mail, we can liken this to the usage of smileys such as :-) or :-( to convey the mood of the message to the reader; unfortunately, authors of literary works do not have access to this indulgence). However, in the writing of a text, the author has to make certain assumptions on the person of his reader – things like social class, background knowledge, and culture can have a great influence on how a reader reacts to a certain work, and while some authors specifically cater their works to a specific audience in mind – like Shakespeare did in writing his plays to satisfy the King – others wrote more open-ended works with no one audience in mind, to cater to a wide range of interpretations.
Conversely, the reader who wants to fully understand a certain piece of work has his work cut out for him as well. In order to elicit the full meaning of a text, consideration has to be given to the context in which it was written. Not withstanding other perfectly valid interpretations of a certain work, the meaning which the author had in mind can only be extracted after the person of the author is made known. And it is this argument that I wish to further in the following paragraphs.
Taking the example of Yeats’ “The Second Coming”, on a first read-through, it seems, to the uninitiated, to be a commentary of the Christian Apocalypse, with words like “tide” and “drowned” lending themselves to flood imagery, and the “Second Coming” obviously heralding the second advent of the Messiah. But what is not obvious, however, is how the poem ties in with Yeats’ gyrical view of history[1], in which the verses that are seemingly irreconcilable with the apocalyptic interpretation, such as the last few lines of the poem, suddenly are full of meaning when subject to interpretation along the lines of his theory:
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come at last,
Slouches to
If one follows the Apocalyptic interpretation here, the least one can do, besides going “Huh?” at these seemingly-unrelated verses, is postulate the birth of an antichrist at Bethlehem after the “darkness” of the Apocalypse “drops” onto mankind. If we interpret this upon knowing Yeats’ gyrical history theory, however, things become much clearer; we can now see that the “darkness” is due to the decline of the Christian era that begun with the “rocking cradle”, and that after the “twenty centuries” of the Christian era passes, the “hour” of a new era has “come round”, emerging with the birth of the “rough beast” marking its beginning. Without discounting the validity of the apocalyptic interpretation, it can easily be seen that Yeats’ original vision of the poem can only be obtained upon being familiar with his way of thinking.
As we continue with Shakespeare’s Macbeth, we have to keep in mind that the impetus behind his work was, contrary to popular belief, not to torture the countless students worldwide who have to know every single detail of his many works, but part of his job as a member of the King’s Players; to entertain the King, and make some money while at it. Macbeth is said to have been written in 1605-6, during the reign of James I, and one of the plays presented during King Christian IV of
Firstly, in homage to the King’s Scottish blood (James I was from Scottish descent, and was said to be descended from the historical Banquo)[3], a Scottish play was written with the prophecy of Banquo’s descendants being one day King (I. iii. 67) – while this was not realised in the play, it could have been said to become reality with James I on the throne. Furthermore, in deference to James I and his belief in the divine right of kings, Shakespeare cleverly worked into the play a contrast between the divine right of Duncan to rule with the demonic tyranny of Macbeth, with Duncan being portrayed as “a most sainted King” (IV. Iii. 109) whose “sacrilegious murder hath broke ope / The Lord’s anointed temple” (II. iii. 61-62), and Macbeth as “a devil . . . damned / In evils” (IV. iii. 57-58).
Another insight can be taken from the usage of the word “equivocator” in the porter scene (II. iii. 10), which significance can only be derived upon knowledge of the Gunpowder Plot in 1605 and the trail of Henry Garnet in 1606 in which he defended the practice of equivocation[4], infusing an otherwise overlooked word with much meaning that cannot be gotten without previous knowledge of Shakespeare and the events that occurred during his time.
In conclusion, we can fully see that although one meaning of works like “The Second Coming” and Macbeth can be derived without much study into the beliefs and times of the author, it is only with research into the context of the work that a meaning in line with the author’s original vision can be fully construed.
[1] In his book ‘A Vision’, Yeats theorised that history is made up of cycles of many successive eras, each starting from a specific event in time (e.g. Christ’s birth), and increasing and decreasing in influence until replaced by the next era. This is further detailed in http://www.yeatsvision.com/History.html.
[2] More on the stage history of Macbeth can be found at http://homepages.rootsweb.com/~maggieoh/Macbeth/history.html.
[3] http://www.britannia.com/history/monarchs/mon46.html.
[4] http://www.gunpowder-plot.org/people/h_garnet.htm.